CASE
Emma, a 19-year-old nursing student, is known for her intelligence, humor, and charismatic personality. Her peers enjoy her company and admire her dedication to becoming a nurse midwife. However, it has been discovered that Emma has been snorting cocaine before attending clinical rotations. This discovery was made by Sarah, a fellow student who stumbled upon Emma’s substance use.
Sarah faces a difficult decision: whether to report Emma’s cocaine use to the faculty or keep it to herself. Reporting Emma might result in severe consequences, including potential expulsion from the nursing program and the destruction of Emma’s dream of becoming a nurse midwife. On the other hand, not reporting Emma could jeopardize patient safety, the integrity of the nursing profession, and Emma’s own health and future.
Instructions & Grading Criteria
I. Introduction
Summarize the key information & events of the case
End with stating the ethical issue in one sentence
Note: An ethical case may have more than one issue depending on different perspectives of different parties; if so, choose one perspective & its’ associated issue
II. Ethical Analysis
Analyze the case by applying two or more ethical principles taught in class (i.e. beneficence, nonmaleficence, respect for autonomy, justice, veracity, fidelity)
Define each ethical principle by paraphrasing a source and cite the source
Adequately explain how each principle applies to the ethical issue & provides guidance in decision making
Use convincing logic
Analyze the case by applying an ethical theory taught in class (i.e., Deontology, Utilitarianism, Virtue Ethics)
Define the ethical theory by paraphrasing a source and cite the source
Adequately explain how the ethical theory applies to the ethical issue & provides guidance in decision making
Use convincing logic
III. Conclusion & Recommendation
Summarize your recommendation regarding the ethical issue
Explain the rationale for your decision
Use convincing logic
V. Overall Criteria
Use the Ethical Analysis Paper template provided
Follow response length guidelines
Use a clear, concise, organized style of writing & correct grammar, punctuation, spelling, and sentence construction
Avoid direct quotes
Reference 2 or more scholarly articles
Use APA formatting for citations & references