This paper is a summary and critique of the article attached. It should be in APA style/12 point Times New Roman and double spaced, Margins should be set to 1″ on every side. the summary and critique of the article should be in past tense, and the implications may be in the present or future tense. Grammar, Spelling and compliance with APA style is important.
*No other material should be cited or referenced*
The article review template is a guide to how the paper should looked like.
This is the rubric:
Professional Article Review
Criteria
Points
Summary
Scholarly
Summary is explicit and detailed. It shows excellent comprehension of the article and its key points.
3 pts
Adequate
Summary is adequate and shows some comprehension of the article and its key points.
2 pts
Needs Improvement
Summary lacks detail and shows little comprehension of the article and its key points.
1 pts
/3 pts
Critique
Scholarly
Critique is backed up with detailed citations of theory and/or research.
3 pts
Adequate
Critique is backed up with some mention of theory and/or research.
2 pts
Needs Improvement
Critique contains no back-up from theory and/or research.
1 pts
/3 pts
Implications
Scholarly
Implications are detailed and thoughtful. The reader can get a clear understanding of how this profession reading is applicable to literacy instruction.
3 pts
Adequate
Implications are mentioned generally, but not explained.
2 pts
Needs Improvement
Implications are not mentioned or not applicable to reading education.
1 pts
/3 pts
APA Style
Scholarly
Use of APA style is correct with almost no errors.
3 pts
Adequate
Use of APA style is mostly correct with minor errors.
2 pts
Needs Improvement
Use of APA style has major errors.
1 pts
/3 pts
Professional Writing
Scholarly
1 or less grammatical and/or spelling errors.
3 pts
Adequate
2-3 grammatical and/or spelling errors.
2 pts
Needs Improvement
3 or more grammatical and/or spelling errors.
1 pts
/3 pts